Personal Injury

Published on: August 25, 2014

Worker Injured on Former’s Employer’s Premises

A recent appellate case arose when a plaintiff was seriously burned after falling into a pool of hot water at the defendant’s chemical plant. The plant had multiple manufacturing units, but the facility was owned by DuPont. The unit where the plaintiff was injured was a formaldehyde production unit. Steam was a key part of the chemical production, and both steam and formaldehyde were supplied by D.B. Western, Inc., which built a formaldehyde manufacturing plant on land adjacent to the chemical plant. Steam pipes ran through the DuPont plant, and through them ran formaldehyde and steam from the adjacent plant.

There were steam traps designed by D.B. Western that DuPont and its outside company Spirex Sarco were responsible for maintaining. In 2004, DuPont sold the formaldehyde unit to Invista, and the employees of DuPont working there, including the plaintiff, became Invista employees. Invista had a contract with the same contracting company to purchase the steam and inspect the pipeline system. The plaintiff was burned by hot condensate that was in a pool under a pipeline.

The plaintiff sued DuPont, the owner of the plant, alleging negligence in the design, construction, and maintenance of the pipeline and steam traps, as well as premises liability. With regard to premises liability, the plaintiff claimed he was an invitee of DuPont. The plaintiff’s wife alleged loss of consortium.

Continue reading →

Published on: August 18, 2014

Death of a Minor in Go-Kart Accident in Texas

By Carabin Shaw

Recently, a 14-year-old girl passed away after a go-kart accident outside the Texas Motor Speedway, where she was participating in a go-kart race. The race was sponsored by the Sports Car Club of America. The girl’s go-kart kept going after she crossed the finish line and crashed through a low fence. Her helmet fell off when she crashed. Although she was airlifted to a hospital, she was pronounced dead afterward. It is not known whether the girl lost control because she suffered some sort of medical condition, or if the go-kart experienced a mechanical failure.

If the cause of an accident causing injury or death to a minor is mechanical failure, it may be appropriate to bring a wrongful death lawsuit. In Texas, a plaintiff bringing a product liability suit must prove the product was defective, the product reached the plaintiff without a substantial change in its condition, the defect made the product unreasonably dangerous, and the defect caused the plaintiff’s injuries and resulting damages.

When a product liability suit is brought, your attorney will need to retain experts to prove whether there was a design, manufacturing, or marketing defect and to testify about whether there was a safer alternative design. When there is a manufacturing defect claim, the plaintiff’s expert must be able to testify that the product deviated from its planned specifications. When there is a marketing defect, the plaintiff will have to show that the product lacked an adequate warning.

Continue reading →

Published on: December 20, 2013

Multi-Million Dollar Verdicts Awarded in Two Separate Topamax Birth Defect Lawsuits – Gurley v. Ortho-McNeil-Janssen Pharmaceutical and Czimmer v. Ortho-McNeil Janssen Pharmaceutical

By Carabin Shaw

On November 18, 2013, a Philadelphia jury awarded over $10 million to a family whose son was born with a cleft palate and other birth defects after being exposed to the drug Topamax during his mother’s pregnancy. More specifically, in Gurley, et al. v. Ortho-McNeil Janssen Pharmaceutical, Haley Powell was prescribed Topamax for treatment of epilepsy and migraines. More than a year after she began taking the drug, she became pregnant and continued to take it throughout her pregnancy after being told by doctors that the drug was safe.

After their son, now five years old, was born with birth defects that will require at least five surgeries before turning age 21, the South Carolina couple sued the drug manufacturer, Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (formerly Ortho-McNeil-Janssen Pharmaceutical) in a Pennsylvania state court. The couple alleged that the company failed to warn the Powells doctor that Topamax taken during pregnancy could cause birth defects, despite the company allegedly being aware of the serious risks as early as 1997. Even though the judge threw out most of plaintiffs’ claims against the drug manufacturer, including strict liability-design defect, negligent design, gross negligence and express breach of warranty, and also barred a bid for punitive damages, the jury ultimately found that Janssen negligently failed to warn the patient and the doctor of the risks associated with Topamax when used by patients during pregnancy and awarded the family over $10 million in damages.

The Gurley case was the second of approximately 134 cases pending in Philadelphia relating to Topamax tried in court. Notably, it is also the second largest verdict in recent months against Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a subsidiary of Johnson and Johnson. In October 2013, a Philadelphia jury in Czimmer v. Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. issued a $4.02 million verdict in favor of April Czimmer, a Virginia woman who took Topamax from August 2006 through February 2007 to treat migraines. Czimmer subsequently gave birth to a boy born with a cleft lip in September 2007. She alleged that she would not have taken the drug for more than six months had she known the risks associated with it. The jury ultimately found that Janssen was negligent when it failed to warn healthcare providers of the extent of the risk of birth defects from Topamax, and awarded approximately $562,000 in future health care costs to Czimmer’s son and an estimated $3.4 million for pain and suffering.

Continue reading →

Published on: October 22, 2013

Immigration Status and its Effect on the Right to Sue for Personal Injury

By Carabin Shaw

According to a recent report by the Pew Research Center, in 2012, an estimated 11.7 million unauthorized immigrants lived in the United States illegally, up from 11.3 million in 2009. The report estimates that approximately 1.75 million of these unauthorized immigrants live in Texas, accounting for 15% of the unauthorized immigrants in the U.S. Moreover, Pew stated that among the six states with the largest numbers of immigrants here illegally, only Texas had a consistent increase in illegal immigration from 2007 to 2011, due in part to its stronger economy. Since many of these immigrants are employed in high-risk occupations, they are at an increased risk to become involved in industrial accidents resulting in personal injury.

Notably, in the U.S., the court system is available to all, and undocumented immigrants have the right to sue those who injure them as a result of negligence. The 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees due process and equal protection of the law to both U.S. citizens and non-citizens. In fact, the term “person” under the 14th Amendment includes U.S. citizens, lawfully admitted residents, and undocumented immigrants. In addition, the Civil Rights Act ensures that all persons within the borders of the U.S. are guaranteed the right to bring lawsuits against those that cause them injury without regard to whether they are in the country legally or not. This means that a person’s immigration status should not preclude his or her right to file a lawsuit in a U.S. or Texas court to recover damages for personal injuries.

Types of Damages Available to Undocumented Immigrants

In a personal injury case the following types of damages may be available: compensation for medical expenses, lost wages or income, and mental pain and suffering. In some jurisdictions, courts have found that allowing the award of back pay and lost wages to undocumented immigrants in personal injury cases circumvents the U.S. Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (“ICRA”). However, courts in Texas have repeatedly reaffirmed the proposition that Texas law does not require citizenship or the possession of immigration work authorization permits as a prerequisite to recovering damages for lost earning capacity.

Continue reading →

Published on: October 15, 2013

Sports and Recreational-Related Activities Contribute to Over 20% of all Traumatic Brain Injuries Amongst Children and Adolescents

By Carabin Shaw

According to the October 2013 issue of the Journal of the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, falls and car accidents are responsible for most cases of minor traumatic brain injuries (“mTBI”). Notably, however, another leading cause of traumatic brain injuries (both minor and severe) is sports and recreational activities. In fact, although infrequent, the leading cause of death from sports-related injuries is traumatic brain injury (“TBI”). Furthermore, sports-and recreational activities contribute to approximately 21% of all TBIs among children and teens.

A traumatic brain injury (“TBI”) is defined as a blow or jolt to the head that disrupts the normal of function of the brain. While mTBIs may result in a concussion without loss of consciousness, more severe traumatic brain injuries can result in extended period unconsciousness, coma, and death. Unfortunately, throughout the beginning of the 21st century, the incidents of TBIs in minors have continued to increase.
According to a report published by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”), from 2001 to 2009, the number of sports and recreation-related emergency room visits for TBI among persons aged 19 and younger increased 62%. In addition, the CDC reports that each year U.S. emergency departments treat an estimated 173,285 sports and recreation related TBIs. Additionally, more recently, a study from Cincinnati Children’s Hospital published on September 30, 2013, showed a 92% increase in pediatric visits to their hospital’s emergency rooms for sports-related traumatic brain injury from 2002 to 2011.

Overall, the activities associated with the most TBI-related emergency room visits include bicycling, football, playground activities, basketball and soccer.
As a result of the increase of TBIs amongst adolescents participating in sports and recreation, many states, schools, and sports leagues and organizations have created policies or action plans on concussions in youth and high school sports. In Texas, for instance, in 2011, the State legislature passed HB 2038 relating to the treatment, prevention, and oversight of concussions affecting public school students participating in interscholastic athletics. The law requires the following:

• The governing body of each school district and open-enrollment charter school with students enrolled who participate in sports appoint or approve a concussion oversight team;
• Parents or guardians of student athletes must sign a form that acknowledges receiving and reading written information that explains among other things, concussion prevention, symptoms, treatment, and guidelines for safely resuming participation in an athletic activity following a concussion; and
• Student athletes are to removed from practice or competition immediately if they are believed to have sustained a concussion during practice or competition, and the student may not be permitted to return until evaluated by a physician.

Continue reading →

Published on: September 22, 2013

Pedestrian Fatality Rates for the State of Texas and Various Texas Cities Grim

By Carabin Shaw

On average, a pedestrian is killed every two hours and injured every eight minutes in traffic crashes. In fact, in 2011, pedestrian deaths accounted for 14% of all traffic fatalities and made up 3% of all people injured in traffic crashes in the United States. According to data from the National Highway Safety Administration (NHTSA), there were 4,432 pedestrian fatalities reported in 2011 due to traffic accidents, an 8% increase since 2009. An estimated 69,000 pedestrians were also injured in traffic crashes. Additionally, the 2011 report by the NHTSA also revealed the following:

• 3 out of every 4 pedestrian deaths occurred in urban areas
• 70% of those killed were at non-intersections
• 70% of pedestrian deaths occurred at night
• Alcohol involvement–either for the driver or the pedestrian–was reported in 48% of all fatal pedestrian crashes
In an effort to combat the rising number of deaths over the last two years and educate communities on safety measures, the U.S. Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx announced a new campaign, “Everyone is a Pedestrian,” in August 2013. Besides providing grants to the cities with the highest rate of pedestrian deaths, the NHTSA, together with the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), launched a website with safety tips and resources for local leaders, officials, parents and other involved in improving pedestrian safety.

Notably, according to the NHTSA, the State of Texas is one of 22 cities in the U.S. where pedestrian deaths are greater than the national average, making Texas eligible to apply for a total of $2 million to be used for education and enforcement initiatives under the campaign. Indeed, Texas pedestrian fatalities account for 14% of the total traffic fatalities in Texas. Unfortunately, at the same time, the Texas cities of San Antonio, Austin, Fort Worth, Houston, and Dallas were also selected by the FHWA in 2011 as focus cities. Focus cities are selected based on the number of pedestrian fatalities or the pedestrian fatality rate per population. More specifically, cities are selected as pedestrian focus cities if they have more than 20 average annual pedestrian fatalities or a pedestrian fatality rate greater than 2.33 per 100,000.

Continue reading →

Published on: September 22, 2013

Stadium Safety Issues Emerge Again after Another Season of Football Begins

By Carabin Shaw

On September 8, 2012, opening weekend of football for the NFL, a spectator fell to his death at San Francisco 49ers stadium while attending the game. The spectator fell to his death from a pedestrian walkway outside of the stadium. Multiple witnesses told police that the victim appeared to be intoxicated at the time of his fall. That very same weekend, two fans were injured when a railing collapsed inside Lucas Oil Stadium, home of the Indianapolis Colts, during a Colts game against the Oakland Raiders. Luckily, neither of these fans were seriously injuries. Unfortunately, however, these incidents are just the latest in a series of deaths and injuries at sports stadiums across the United States over the past several years.

Recent Accidents

According to the Institute for the Study of Sports Incidents, based at the University of Southern Mississippi, since 2003 there have been more than two-dozen cases of fans falling at stadiums across the country. On August 13, 2013, an Atlanta Braves fan was killed at Turner Field in Atlanta after falling 85 feet from a fourth-level railing of the stadium onto a parking lot below. In addition, during a pre-season NFL football game this year, a Denver Broncos fan was injured when he fell 10 feet from an escalator. Finally, at Rangers Ballpark in Arlington, Texas in 2011, a spectator fell to this death from the left-field seats after trying to catch a ball tossed towards him.

Premises Liability

In addition to complying with local and states laws, all stadiums must also comply with the strict safety guidelines instituted by the International Building Code, which has been adopted by all 50 states and the District of Colombia. Among the guidelines are various railing requirements, including calls for railings in front of seats to be at least 26 inches high, and a requirement that protective railings placed in open-sided areas such as concourses be at least 42 inches in height.

Continue reading →

Published on: September 13, 2013

Recent Recalls Affecting Infants and Young Children in Texas and Elsewhere

By Carabin Shaw

Every year thousands of infants sustain injuries or are wrongfully killed by dangerous and defective products. In addition, deaths, injuries and property damage from consumer product incidents in general cost the nation more than $900 billion annually. Unfortunately, many of these injuries are caused by the negligence or recklessness of manufacturers and distributors, meaning that many of these injuries and deaths could be avoided.

Infants are particularly vulnerable to dangerous and defective products, including but not limited to toys, clothing, and even drugs. According to a 2011 report produced by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSIA), among children younger than 5 years of age, there were an estimated 74,100 emergency department-treated injuries, associated with, though not necessarily caused by, nursery products in 2011. In addition, for the 3-year period from 2007 through 2009, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) received reports of 341 deaths, associated with, but not necessarily caused by, nursery products among children younger than age 5. Several recalls relating to products used by infants have been reported in the past few months, including but not limited to the following:

HALO SleepSacks Recalled

On August 21, 2013, the CPSC issued a recall of approximately 27,000 HALO SleepSacks Wearable Blankets sold exclusively at Babies R Us and babiesrus.com from December 2011 through July 2013. Citing a risk of a choking hazard to infants, the CPSC advised consumers to stop using the product immediately. The recall was issued after the CPSC received six separate reports of a pink satin flower on the blankets becoming detached from the blankets. In one case, the report complained that an infant was discovered gagging on the detached petal.

Continue reading →

Published on: September 12, 2013

After Influx of Recent Cases of Brain-Eating Amoeba Reported, CDC Expands Access to Experimental New Drug

By Carabin Shaw

On September 7, 2013, a child (believed to be a 4-year old boy from Mississippi) died after contracting a rare, but deadly, brain-eating infection while visiting Louisiana. The boy may have come into contact with the waterborne brain-eating amoeba, known doctors as scientist as Naegleria fowleri, while playing on a plastic toy water slide at a home in St. Bernard’s Parish, Louisiana. According to the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals, water samples taken from the home the child was visiting tested positive for amoeba.

Unfortunately, this was not the only story of a child becoming infected with the brain-eating amoeba reported recently. On August 3, 2013, a 12-year old South Florida boy was knee-boarding in ditch water in Glades County, Florida when he contracted primary amebic meningoencephalitis (PAM), the infection caused by the Naegleria fowleri amoeba, through his nose. Although antibiotics successfully fought off the infection, the boy suffered extensive brain damage, which left him on life support. The boy passed away on August 27, 2013. Finally, in July 2013, a 12-year old became ill after contracting the brain-eating parasite at a waterpark in Arkansas. However, she is one of the few individuals who managed to survive the infection after being treating with the experimental drug miltefosine, and was released from the hospital on September 11, 2013.

Despite the recent occurrences of infections, officials from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) report that only 128 people have been infected with PAM from 1962 to 2012. Of these 128 people, only two people in North America survived. In the future, this survival rate may increase as the CDC recently expanded doctors’ access to the experimental new drug, miltefosine, to treat deadly viruses, including PAM. Although used to treat another parasitic infection called leishmaniasis, and sometimes breast cancer, the drug was previously only used in emergency situations with permission from the FDA to treat PAM.

Continue reading →

Published on: August 18, 2013

The Summer of 2013 Has Not Been Kind to Airplane Safety

By Carabin Shaw

Although air travel is typically one of the safest ways to travel, when accidents happen they are often deadly. According to the Aviation Safety Network, 2012 was the safest for the airline industry, with only 23 deadly accidents and 475 fatalities worldwide. However, 2013 may not prove to be as safe. On August 14, 2013, the pilot and co-pilot of a large UPS cargo plane were killed when the plane crashed and burst into flames during its approach to the airport Birmingham, Alabama. Response teams with the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) were immediately called to the scene. According to the NTSB, a flight recorder revealed that the pilots received warnings about their rate of descent just seconds before impact.

At the time of the crash, the plane was being flown by the captain, who had 8,600 hours of flight experience, including 3,200 hours in an A300, the type of plane involved in the crash. Notably, the pilots were attempting a landing on Runway 18, which can be a tricky runway, even for the most experienced pilots. Due to the fact that there is a large hill and trees at one end of the runway, the runway lacks the electronics for a full instrument landing, which forces pilots to make judgments about altitude on a shorter runway. In addition, fatigue could have also played a role in the accident. Preliminary information indicates that the pilots began working at 9:30 p.m. in Rockford, Illinois the night before the crash. At the time of the crash shortly before 5:00 a.m. local time, the pilots were completing their third flight of the night.

This crash comes in the wake of several other plane crashes in the United States over the past several months. On July 6, 2013, three people were killed, and 180 injured when Asiana Airline Flight 214 clipped the seawall on the runway at San Francisco International Airport. Notably, one of three individuals killed survived the plane crash only to be run over by a rescue vehicle in the aftermath of the crash. On August 12, 2013, Asiana Airlines revealed that it is paying $10,000 to each of the passengers aboard Flight 214, exclusive of medical compensation. Even those individuals who were not injured can receive the money, and those passengers who collect money can still file lawsuits against the airline.

Continue reading →